A New Papacy, A New Chance: Three Lessons for the Next Pope from Pope Francis’ Failures to Address Sexual Abuse
With the passing of Pope Francis, the world mourns a leader who brought warmth, humility, and a progressive spirit to one of the oldest institutions on earth. His papacy marked a profound shift in tone for the Catholic Church—one defined by concern for the poor, care for the environment, and outreach to those long marginalized by doctrine or tradition. For many, he was a pope of the people: a shepherd who walked with his flock and reminded the Church of its roots in compassion.
Yet even as we honor the grace and conviction with which he led, one painful and unresolved chapter continues to cast a long shadow over his papacy: the Catholic Church’s ongoing mishandling of the sexual abuse crisis.
Pope Francis did not ignore the crisis. He offered apologies. He met with survivors. He spoke of the need for change. And at times, he challenged the culture of silence that had protected abusers for generations. But for many survivors, the steps he took—though well-meaning—fell short of the transparency, accountability, and systemic reform they so desperately needed.
Now, as the Church prepares to choose a new spiritual leader, it must also confront the moral crossroads it stands upon. To honor Pope Francis’ legacy of compassion, the Church must do what he began but did not finish: face the full truth of its failings and commit to healing and justice.
Here are three essential steps the Church must take in this next chapter:
Center Survivors—Not Institutions
One of the enduring criticisms of Francis’ papacy was the perception that the Church’s reputation often took precedence over the lived experience of those harmed. While some bishops were removed, others remained in positions of power despite credible accusations or evidence of complicity.
True reform begins when survivors are no longer treated as an afterthought. Future leadership must place survivors at the center of its mission—not just in words, but through concrete action. This includes transparent investigations, removing abusers and their protectors, and creating survivor-led forums that uphold dignity, validation, and restorative justice.
Go Beyond Symbolism—Make Truth Public
Pope Francis held private meetings with abuse survivors that were meant to convey personal compassion. But survivors need more than closed-door encounters—they need public acknowledgment, systemic accountability, and visible solidarity from the highest levels of Church leadership.
The next pope must move beyond apology alone. Healing demands tangible steps: opening archives, naming perpetrators, cooperating fully with civil authorities, and offering reparations. Words of sorrow must be matched by acts of courage and transparency.
Take Responsibility—Without Deflection
At times, Francis framed abuse as a tragedy that exists across all institutions, not just the Church. While true, this framing sometimes came across as a deflection—an unwillingness to fully claim the Church’s unique responsibility in fostering a culture of silence and protectionism.
The next chapter of leadership must reject defensiveness and embrace accountability. The Catholic Church’s crisis is not simply a reflection of societal failures; it is a specific betrayal of moral and spiritual trust. Any meaningful path forward must involve dismantling the structures that enabled abuse, embracing external oversight, and recommitting to moral authority through acts—not intentions.
A Call to Courage
Pope Francis leaves behind a legacy rich in humility and hope. He reminded the Church to look outward, to care more, to judge less. But even his most devoted admirers acknowledge that the work of justice for survivors remains painfully incomplete.
Now is not the time to soften the truth or delay the reckoning. It is time to finish the work Pope Francis began, and in some ways struggled to complete. A Church that truly lives out the Gospel must confront its deepest wounds—not with platitudes, but with integrity, transparency, and a fierce commitment to justice.
Survivors have waited long enough.
May this moment be not only one of mourning, but of moral awakening. May the next leader of the Catholic Church carry forward Pope Francis’ heart—but with the resolve to do what is long overdue.